Hanging by the
Supreme Court’s Tail
in the Nilgiri hills of Tamil Nadu, pristine rosewood forests are now
witness to rampant encroachments with the help of forest officials and
politicians despite the apex court’s order. Keya Acharya
you are ever offered a drive from Gudalur in the Nilgiri hills of Tamil
Nadu, 40 km from Ooty, down to the foothill district of Malappuram in
Kerala, take it up. The road traverses through amazing tropical rainforests
like Africa’s, deep, dense and surrealistically remote, considering
the din of Gudalur nearby.
Victim: Vadivelu, 65, faces eviction from Amekula village
Photos: Keya Acharya
secretary named 642 violators and ordered contempt proceedings,
but nothing has come out of these
more surprises, these are ‘private’ forests, part of 80,087.74
acres, once thick with rosewood trees and teeming with wildlife, belonging
to the rajas of Nilambur (Nilambur Kovilakam), governed by the Tamil Nadu
Preservation of Private Forest Act, 1949.
janmam lands (principality land) were then acquired by the government
through the Janmam Lands (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act,
since the Act’s implementation in 1974, these beautiful forests,
sadly excluded from the protection of the UN-recognised Nilgiri biosphere,
have faced nothing but a cauldron of deforestation, corruption and complicated
Act prohibits pattas on forested janmam lands (Section 11), but gives
ownership of lands cultivated continuously for three years prior to 1969
to janmis (original purchasers) and 99-year lessees from Nilambur Kovilakam
(Section 8), in turn to their lessees (Section 9) and to anyone else falling
under the ‘continuous cultivation’ rule (Section 10). Section
17 empowers the government to renew or terminate all pattas. The Act so
far has settled 9,272.49 acres under janmis, 5,886.54 acres as ‘waste
lands’ (Section 15) and 12,928 acres as forests (Section 53).
is the remaining 52,000.71 acres, including 91 plantations, 11 of which
are major, that has given rise to a continuing controversy. As per original
leases signed with Nilambur Kovilakam, the area under plantations should
be 19,644.19 acres, with a further 32,356.52 acres as ‘undeveloped
latter 32,356.52 acres together with 12,928 acres declared forests under
Section 53, supposedly under government protection, are now facing rampant
encroachments through fraudulent leases, illegal pattas, direct usurpation
and increased plantation-acreage, all through active connivance of officials
and plantation owners. No one case has been penalised so far.
1995, Godavarman Thirumulpad of Nilambur Kovilakam petitioned the Supreme
Court (SC) to take the state government to task and prevent such encroachments.
The court took his petition (202/95), popularly known as the Forest Case,
and clubbed it with several countrywide forest cases appointing an Amicus
Curiae as overseer. The SC then prohibited felling, pattas and regularisation
of encroachments on janmam forests, asking Tamil Nadu to file a status
report. Tamil Nadu’s chief secretary reported 642 persons, including
plantations, as violators and ordered contempt proceedings against them
in July 2003. Nothing has come of these.
May 2003, a five-member Central Empowered Committee (CEC) consisting of
SC advocates, ministry of environment and forest (moef) officials and
an ngo representative appointed by the court in the ‘forest case’,
visited these janmam lands and reported further serious illegalities.
Glenrock Tea Estate, for instance, has cardamom plantations by an encroacher,
Gowrishankar, besides a road cut illegally through 3,560 acres of pristine
forests to smuggle timber all the way to Kerala, under the knowledge of
the Conservator of Forests (CF), Coimbatore Circle, T. Sekar. Godavarman
has charged Sekar and the Tamil Nadu government with producing a doctored
Survey of India (si) sheet showing the road’s prior existence.
1,000 acres of the Manjushree Plantations, leased from Nilambur Kovilakam
in 1845, now with the Birla group, have been encroached by approximately
six individuals who obtained pattas from the assistant settlement officer,
revenue department, Pandurangan, who deliberately ignored the dfo’s
statement that pattas could not be granted in these forests under the
Private Forests’ Act. Pandurangan promptly retired thereafter. The
dfo’s subsequent appeal to the Survey and Settlement Director in
Chennai in January 1999 cancelled these pattas, but the occupants obtained
a stay and continue to this day. So do fresh encroachments, a large number
of them migrants from Kerala.
to Manjushree Plantations, on Section 53 forests, James Jacob, an advocate
from Kerala, has encroached extensively, building a huge bungalow and
appropriating an entire stream by cordoning it with electrified fencing,
obstructing elephants and wildlife from drinking water.
least 38 leaders from
the ADMK, DMK and Congress are encroachers, with the CPM being the
human rights group, Peoples’ Union for Civil Liberties, says at
least 38 local leaders from the admk, dmk and Congress parties are encroachers,
with the cpm apparently the only exception. PR Chandramohan, booked as
an encroacher of 150 acres in Devala, was appointed as government pleader
for forests from 2001 to 2003. He sent several threat letters to the then
dfo, Deepak Srivastava, warning him off his lands.
always each and different issue you hanging in the tail of the Supreme
Court wp 202/95”, wrote Chandramohan to Srivastava. “You are
always misusing the Hon’ble SC order by way of threatening…evicted
the landholder those who are already in possession and enjoyment.”
(SIC) Chandramohan was subsequently removed from his post in 2003.
most prominent politician who reported complicity by the CEC to the SC,
is the present Tourism Minister Andrew Millar, mla from Gudalur.
2001, Millar requested the chief minister to transfer three forest staff,
typist Krishna Kumar, foresters Prem Sagar and Kundan and dfo Srivastava.
Srivastava, then evicting encroachers under the forest case, said that
Millar’s request came because his father-in-law, Ponnaniyan Nadar,
was prevented from encroaching 100 acres in O’Valley. Srivastava
was transferred in April 2002, while Kumar was suspended on flimsy grounds.
After Srivastava’s transfer, encroachers moved back, while fresh
encroachments continue to this day.
fact, Tamil Nadu’s official forest-related machinery has been distinctive
in victimising those discharging their duties. Prem Sagar and Krishna
Kumar, members of the Tamil Nadu Forest Staff Association, were transferred
without designated posts in quick succession to Erode, Dindigul, Coimbatore.
Kundan, president of the association, had been writing to the collector,
chief secretary and others on the illegal goings-on in Gudalur forests
from 2000, requesting action. Krishna Kumar was suspended when he and
the others apprised the CEC in 2003 of illegal encroachments in Gudalur.
officials appear to have played an active role in victimising and harassing
the staff,” says the CEC, wanting a thorough probe into the conduct
of CF Sekar, dfos Dinkar Kumar and AK Ulaganathan, described as “totally
ineffective” and apparently aware of illegal goings-on in their
is irking local communities now is that small-time livelihood encroachers
are being evicted summarily by the forest department, in apparent compliance
of the forest case orders, whilst nothing is being done about these ‘big-timers’.